4.9 Google Rating

(280+ Reviews)

Get Started in Minutes.
Save Hundreds.
Talk to a Real Human.

Message an Expert Now — Get Real Savings Fast.

(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Brad, Brooklyn, or Kyle — Not a Call Center.)

*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up Required.

Get Started in Minutes.

Save Hundreds.

Talk to a Real Human.

Message an Expert Now
— Get Real Savings Fast.​

(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Brad, Brooklyn, or Kyle — Not a Call Center.)

*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.

*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up required.

Insurance in Wauwatosa, WI

We Shop. You Save. It's That Simple

At Joseph Hoell Insurance, Wauwatosa families and drivers get insurance advice from people who live right here. As a local, independent agency—not a distant call center—we compare top carriers to find better options for you. Most locals save hundreds each year with our personal help and honest service.

TOP RATED

Auto Insurance

Save money. Get covered fast. Local help, no hassle.

TOP RATED

Home Insurance

Protect your home. No gaps, no games, just honest coverage.

“Joe has over 250 5 star Google reviews for a reason! Not only did he save me over $1,800 dollars a year, but he was also able to give me better coverage then what I previously had!”  –  Julia O.

Need Coverage for Something Else?

Renters Insurance

Protect your stuff from fire, theft, and what landlords don’t cover.

Condo Insurance

Gaps in your HOA coverage? We cover what matters inside your condo.

Motorcycle Insurance

Get coverage that keeps your bike safe and your ride legal.

Boat Insurance

Easy boat coverage—so you can enjoy the water with less worry.

SR-22 Insurance

SR-22 filing made easy—quick, judgment-free, and affordable.

Other Specialty Insurance

Looking for Something Else?

Wauwatosa, WI’s Insider Move for Easy Insurance

Better Protection + Fewer Headaches.

Insurance shouldn’t be confusing or feel like a game. Here in Wauwatosa, we keep things honest. No hidden costs. No hype. No pressure. We’re your neighbors. As a local Wisconsin agency, we compare quotes from 20+ approved insurers and show you the options side-by-side — in plain English. You get the facts, and you only pay for what actually makes sense for you. And if you’re just looking, that’s more than fine — there’s never any obligation to sign up.

Real, Local Agents, Not Call Centers.

Talk to the same local insurance expert every time.

We Shop 20+ Carriers for You—Free.​

You Get the Best Deal. We Handle the Shopping. 

No Extras.
No Overpaying.

Only what you need. Nothing you don’t.

Meet Your Insurance Agents

Real People. Local Help. No Call Centers.

Joseph Hoell

Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency

Brad Zacharias

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Brooklyn Walker

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Kyle Kollmar

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

What Wauwatosa Families Discovered After Making the Switch

Real stories from neighbors who switched both auto and home insurance — and finally felt at ease.

Ready to Find Your Best Rate?

It’s fast, free, and there’s zero pressure. You don’t even have to sign up.

Prefer to talk?
Call (262) 214-0999 or email info@hoellagency.com

Questions People Ask Before Switching to Us

Absolutely, no cost at all. We provide free insurance quotes for auto, home, renters, and more. You can call, email, or stop by our Wisconsin office—we never charge just to show you your options. You don’t have to sign up, and there’s no pressure. We’re here to help you find affordable coverage that fits your needs.
Definitely. Bundling car and home insurance with a Wisconsin agent can often save you money. It’s a simple way to get discounts and manage everything with one point of contact. We’ll walk you through your options and show what works best for you. You don’t have to make any decisions on the spot. Let’s see if a bundle makes sense for your budget.
Yes, we help with SR-22 insurance across Wisconsin. Whether it’s for a recent traffic issue or a court requirement, we can explain what’s needed and how to file. Getting back on the road isn’t as tough as it sounds. Reach out with questions—there’s no judgment and no commitment required. We’ll make the whole process clear.
We work with over 20 trusted insurance carriers in Wisconsin. That means you see real rates—not just the lowest teaser. We’ll explain the differences so you know exactly what you’re getting. No pressure, no hidden info. Our job is to make insurance simple, honest, and easy to compare.
We can help you with car, home, renters, condo, motorcycle, boat, and SR-22 insurance throughout Wisconsin. We’re happy to answer questions about what fits your needs and budget. You can get guidance with zero obligation. If you’re not sure what you need, we’ll help you figure it out.
That’s perfectly fine. Many of our customers already have coverage before reaching out. We offer side-by-side comparisons—sometimes that means better rates or coverage. But there’s no pressure to leave your current company. We’re here to give you honest advice either way.
Absolutely. You can call or stop by our Wisconsin agency to talk to a real, local agent. No call centers, no robots. We take time to understand your needs and explain your options. You can get answers to any insurance question—no obligation, just help.
Most times, it’s same-day. We work quickly to get you proof of coverage—perfect if you need car insurance for a new car or an SR-22 right away. No waiting for weeks. If you need help right away, just let us know. We’ll make it as easy as possible.
No pressure, ever. Our main goal is to make insurance decisions easy for everyone in Wisconsin. If your current plan is the best fit, we’ll tell you. Our quotes are honest and always no-obligation. You only switch if it makes sense for you.
Local agents know Wisconsin insurance inside and out. We’re not a big national brand—we live and work right here. We care about helping neighbors get fair, affordable coverage. You never have to guess what’s best—we’ll help you figure it out at every step.

How Insurance Fits Into Everyday Life in Wauwatosa, WI

If you ask me, living in Wauwatosa feels a bit like you’ve stumbled onto a small town hiding in the middle of the city. Folks take time to chat in line at Simma’s Bakery, and it’s not unusual to see neighbors walking their dogs or kids bundled up at Hart Park even when the weather’s stubborn. There’s never a dull season — you notice when winter gives way to spring just by the smell of the thaw and the way the lawns start greening up. It’s honest, everyday living around here, and that’s part of the charm.

Auto Insurance That Fits Wauwatosa Drivers

If you’ve driven down North Avenue at rush hour, you know what real traffic feels like. There’s always that pothole by the library nobody can seem to avoid, and during those icy January mornings, everyone seems to shuffle along with both hands on the wheel. In the fall, you’ve got to watch for those wet leaves turning the roads slick, and I’ve seen more than one fender bender in the Village after a sudden rainstorm. We talk insurance because we’ve been there — waiting for the plows to clear the side streets, calling in for repairs after a deer made the wrong decision by Underwood Creek. We get it.

Home Insurance That Makes Sense in Wauwatosa

Some houses here go way back — creaky, lovely places around Washington Highlands or the brick two-story homes tucked into the 53213 zip code. Every season brings its share of headaches. We’ve all seen what a hailstorm does to a roof or how a single cold snap can freeze pipes that were just fine last winter. The rain sometimes causes puddles where you wish it wouldn’t, and the wind can send a neighbor’s branch tumbling onto the porch in no time. Home policies need to actually reflect all that, not just something off a website. That’s what we look at when we help you.

Trusted Local Insurance Agency

We’re not a franchise and there’s no out-of-state call center answering when you ring us up. It’s just us — neighbors who live and work right here. At Joseph Hoell Insurance, we compare over 20 carriers to find options for you, but you won’t get any pressure from us. We’d rather be honest and help you figure things out than push you into something that doesn’t fit. No tricks, just real help and clear answers.

Thanks for taking a minute to check us out. Questions or just want to talk over your coverage? We’re here — just give us a call or swing by if you’re near enough.

Resources and Local Information

City of Wauwatosa, WI Official Website

Wauwatosa, WI Map

Neighboring Communities

Brookfield

Elm Grove

Glendale

Waukesha

West Allis

Shorewood

Greenfield

Milwaukee

Whitefish Bay

New Berlin

More Service Areas Pages

Milwaukee, WI
West Allis, WI