4.9 Google Rating
(280+ Reviews)
Get Started in Minutes.
Save Hundreds.
Talk to a Real Human.
Message an Expert Now — Get Real Savings Fast.
(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Brad, Brooklyn, or Kyle — Not a Call Center.)
*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up Required.
Get Started in Minutes.
Save Hundreds.
Talk to a Real Human.
Message an Expert Now
— Get Real Savings Fast.
(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Brad, Brooklyn, or Kyle — Not a Call Center.)
*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up required.
Insurance in Sussex, WI
We Shop. You Save. It's That Simple
Looking for insurance in Sussex? Joseph Hoell Insurance is your local, independent agency—right here in the community. We compare trusted carriers to help Sussex families and drivers get smarter coverage. Most folks save hundreds per year, plus you get real local support when you need it most.
TOP RATED
Auto Insurance
TOP RATED
Home Insurance
“Joe has over 250 5 star Google reviews for a reason! Not only did he save me over $1,800 dollars a year, but he was also able to give me better coverage then what I previously had!” – Julia O.
Need Coverage for Something Else?
Sussex, WI’s Shortcut to Insurance That Actually Makes Sense
Better Protection + Fewer Headaches.
Finding insurance in Sussex shouldn’t come with surprises. We’re local—right here in Wisconsin—and we do things differently. No hidden fees. No pressure. No fine print you have to worry about. At Joseph Hoell Insurance, we compare 20+ Wisconsin-approved insurance companies for you so you get honest options at the best rates. Everything’s explained in plain English, so you only pay for what you actually need and nothing more. There’s never any rush. You don’t have to sign up if you’re not ready.
Real, Local Agents, Not Call Centers.
Talk to the same local insurance expert every time.
We Shop 20+ Carriers for You—Free.
You Get the Best Deal. We Handle the Shopping.
No Extras.
No Overpaying.
Only what you need. Nothing you don’t.
Meet Your Insurance Agents
Real People. Local Help. No Call Centers.
Joseph Hoell
Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency
Brad Zacharias
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Brooklyn Walker
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Kyle Kollmar
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
What Happened When Sussex Families Made the Switch to Us
Neighbors who switched their auto and home insurance here say things finally got simpler—and the savings felt real.
Ready to Find Your Best Rate?
It’s fast, free, and there’s zero pressure. You don’t even have to sign up.
Prefer to talk?
Call (262) 214-0999 or email info@hoellagency.com
Questions People Ask Before Switching to Us
Real Talk About Insurance Coverage in Sussex, WI
On any given evening in Sussex, you can hear screens slapping shut as mosquitoes start up, or see neighbors out walking the dog along Main Street. Folks here look out for each other — whether that’s waving at the postman, or clearing driveways after the plows go by. There’s a rhythm to this place. Life runs a little more by the seasons, and you always know who’s behind you in the drive-thru at the pick ‘n save.
Auto Insurance That Fits Sussex Drivers
If you spend enough time driving Sussex roads — whether it’s Silver Spring, Good Hope, or just dodging potholes on Maple Avenue — you notice the stuff that’s not in the driver’s manual. Sudden deer at dusk, that weird corner under the train tracks where black ice lurks, or hail that can flatten your hood in ten minutes flat. You need auto protection that actually fits what goes on around here. Our whole crew drives these same stretches, so when you mention a fender bender near 164 or a windshield chipped on the way through 53089, you’re talking to someone who’s been there.
Home Insurance That Makes Sense in Sussex
Homes in ZIP 53089 aren’t all the same. There’s old farmhouses with big yards, and those new two-stories squeezed in by the new elementary school. But no matter which one is yours, we’ve all seen burst pipes in February, tree branches on the roof after a storm, or basement floods when that spring thaw hits hard. You don’t need coverage for “somewhere else.” You need coverage that gets what Sussex weather — and Sussex living — can actually dish out.
Trusted Local Insurance Agency
We’re your neighbors, not a number you get bounced around on. Joseph Hoell Insurance is right here in town — real people who sit across from you, not behind a screen in a big city office. We check rates with over 20 insurance carriers, so you don’t have to make ten phone calls or mess with quotes online. No hurrying or haggling. If we don’t think something’s right for you, we’ll tell you straight. We just want you to feel good about how you’re covered, no tricks needed.
Really, thanks for taking a look. If you need help or you’re just curious about what a real local agency can do, just give a shout or stop by — we’re here for you.
Neighboring Communities
Pewaukee
Hartland
Lisbon
Colgate
Menomonee Falls
Brookfield
Butler
Lannon
Merton
Germantown











