4.9 Google Rating

(307+ Reviews)

Helping Sussex Neighbors Find Better Coverage with Less Stress.

We help you compare coverage, understand the options, and choose what fits best.

(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Kyle, Whitney, Megan or Tarah — Not a Call Center.)

*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up Required.

Helping Sussex Neighbors Find Better Coverage with Less Stress.

We help you compare coverage, understand the options, and choose what fits best.

(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Kyle, Whitney, Megan, or Tarah — Not a Call Center.)

*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.

*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up required.

Insurance in Sussex, WI

Looking for insurance in Sussex? Joseph Hoell Insurance is your local, independent agency—right here in the community. We compare trusted carriers to help Sussex families and drivers get smarter coverage. Most folks save hundreds per year, plus you get real local support when you need it most.

Meet Your Insurance Agents

Joseph Hoell Insurance Agency Owner

Joseph Hoell

Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency

Kyle Kollmer Insurance Agent

Kyle Kollmar

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Whitney Kovacs Germantown Wisconsin Insurance Agent

Whitney Kovacs

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Megan Parmenter Wisconsin Insurance Agent

Megan Parmenter

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Tarah McKay Wisconsin Insurance Agent

Tarah McKay​​

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Joseph Hoell

Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency

Kyle Kollmar

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Whitney Kovacs​

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Megan Parmenter  

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Tarah McKay​

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Megan Parmenter  

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Tarah McKay​

Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency

Why Choose an Independent Insurance Agency?

Real, Local Agents

Talk to the same local insurance expert every time.

More Than One Carrier

You Get the Best Deal. We Handle the Shopping. 

Coverage That Fits You

Only what you need. Nothing you don’t.

Home & Auto Insurance Coverage in ​Sussex

Auto Insurance

Save big. Fast, friendly quotes. Local help every mile.

Home Insurance

Protect your home and wallet — fair rates, no hidden games.

Auto Insurance

Compare coverage, rates, and options with help from a local agent.

Home Insurance

Review your home insurance options with local guidance you can trust.

Other Specialty Insurance

We Can Help Beyond Home and Auto

“Joe has over 250 5 star Google reviews for a reason! Not only did he save me over $1,800 dollars a year, but he was also able to give me better coverage then what I previously had!”  –  Julia O.

Sussex, WI’s Shortcut to Insurance That Actually Makes Sense

Better Protection + Fewer Headaches.

Finding insurance in Sussex shouldn’t come with surprises. We’re local—right here in Wisconsin—and we do things differently. No hidden fees. No pressure. No fine print you have to worry about. At Joseph Hoell Insurance, we compare 10+ Wisconsin-approved insurance companies for you so you get honest options at the best rates. Everything’s explained in plain English, so you only pay for what you actually need and nothing more. There’s never any rush. You don’t have to sign up if you’re not ready.

What Happened When Sussex Families Made the Switch to Us

Neighbors who switched their auto and home insurance here say things finally got simpler—and the savings felt real.

Need Help Finding the Right Coverage?

It’s free, easy, and there’s no pressure. You can message a local agent or call us when you’re ready.

Prefer to talk?
Call (262) 214-0999 or email info@hoellagency.com

Questions People Ask Before Switching to Us

Yes, absolutely. Getting an insurance quote is free and straightforward. You don’t have to sign up to see your rates, and there are no hidden fees or strings attached. We want you to feel comfortable exploring your options. If you’re just curious about auto, home, or renters insurance, that’s perfectly fine. We’re here to help you compare, not pressure you into anything.
Absolutely! Lots of drivers and homeowners in Wisconsin switch to us from another company. We’ll help you compare your current policy to what’s available now. Sometimes, you’ll get more coverage for less. There’s never any pressure to change. If your current policy is still the best fit, we’ll tell you. Our goal is to make sure you’re happy and protected.
We help with auto, home, renters, condo, SR-22, motorcycle, and even boat insurance. Whether you need coverage for your car or your place, we’ve got options through top Wisconsin-approved carriers. You can ask us anything about affordable insurance for your situation. We’ll help you find what actually fits your needs.
Nope, not at all. You can get your quote completely online or over the phone. If you ever want to meet in person, our Wisconsin office is always open. But there’s no need to leave home if you don’t want to. We make it easy for you to get car or home insurance however you’re most comfortable.
We compare rates from over 10 top Wisconsin insurance carriers. That way, you get real choices, not just a single company’s offer. We’ll show you the pros and cons in plain English. No bait-and-switch quotes—just what’s actually available for your car or truck. You decide when you’re ready.
Yes, we work with plenty of providers that offer SR-22 insurance in Wisconsin. We make the process simple, helping you file any forms you need. If you have questions about your specific situation, just ask. You don’t have to commit until you know it’s a good fit.
Definitely. You’ll speak with a real Wisconsin agent who understands the local ins and outs. No out-of-state call centers or automated hotlines, just friendly help from someone who knows the area. We explain everything in plain language, so you feel at home and well taken care of.
Yes, bundling home and auto insurance often saves you money. We’ll check rates with several Wisconsin carriers to find the best package for you. No pressure to bundle if it doesn’t actually help. We’re happy to show side-by-side options so you can pick what works best for your family.
Absolutely. We write renters and condo insurance policies every week right here in Wisconsin. Coverage is often more affordable than people think. Ask for a quote—even if you’re just comparing. We’ll help you protect your things without charging you for stuff you don’t need.
Never. You can take as much time as you need to look over your quotes and ask questions. We’re here to give honest advice and local support. No pushy sales tactics. If you just want to see what’s out there, that’s perfectly fine. You decide if and when you want to move forward.

Real Talk About Insurance Coverage in Sussex, WI

On any given evening in Sussex, you can hear screens slapping shut as mosquitoes start up, or see neighbors out walking the dog along Main Street. Folks here look out for each other — whether that’s waving at the postman, or clearing driveways after the plows go by. There’s a rhythm to this place. Life runs a little more by the seasons, and you always know who’s behind you in the drive-thru at the pick ‘n save.

Auto Insurance That Fits Sussex Drivers

If you spend enough time driving Sussex roads — whether it’s Silver Spring, Good Hope, or just dodging potholes on Maple Avenue — you notice the stuff that’s not in the driver’s manual. Sudden deer at dusk, that weird corner under the train tracks where black ice lurks, or hail that can flatten your hood in ten minutes flat. You need auto protection that actually fits what goes on around here. Our whole crew drives these same stretches, so when you mention a fender bender near 164 or a windshield chipped on the way through 53089, you’re talking to someone who’s been there.

Home Insurance That Makes Sense in Sussex

Homes in ZIP 53089 aren’t all the same. There’s old farmhouses with big yards, and those new two-stories squeezed in by the new elementary school. But no matter which one is yours, we’ve all seen burst pipes in February, tree branches on the roof after a storm, or basement floods when that spring thaw hits hard. You don’t need coverage for “somewhere else.” You need coverage that gets what Sussex weather — and Sussex living — can actually dish out.

Trusted Local Insurance Agency

We’re your neighbors, not a number you get bounced around on. Joseph Hoell Insurance is right here in town — real people who sit across from you, not behind a screen in a big city office. We check rates with over 10 insurance carriers, so you don’t have to make ten phone calls or mess with quotes online. No hurrying or haggling. If we don’t think something’s right for you, we’ll tell you straight. We just want you to feel good about how you’re covered, no tricks needed.

Really, thanks for taking a look. If you need help or you’re just curious about what a real local agency can do, just give a shout or stop by — we’re here for you.

Resources and Local Information

City of Sussex, WI Official Website

Sussex, WI Map

Neighboring Communities

Pewaukee

Hartland

Lisbon

Colgate

Menomonee Falls

Brookfield

Butler

Lannon

Merton

Germantown

More Service Areas Pages