4.9 Google Rating
(280+ Reviews)
Get Started in Minutes.
Save Hundreds.
Talk to a Real Human.
Message an Expert Now — Get Real Savings Fast.
(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Brad, Brooklyn, or Kyle — Not a Call Center.)
*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up Required.
Get Started in Minutes.
Save Hundreds.
Talk to a Real Human.
Message an Expert Now
— Get Real Savings Fast.
(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Brad, Brooklyn, or Kyle — Not a Call Center.)
*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up required.
Insurance in Cedarburg, WI
We Shop. You Save. It's That Simple
At Joseph Hoell Insurance, we’re proud to help Cedarburg families, drivers, and neighbors find insurance that truly fits their lives. As your local, independent agency, we compare top carriers so you get honest options. Most clients save hundreds each year—while getting coverage they can trust from folks nearby.
TOP RATED
Auto Insurance
TOP RATED
Home Insurance
“Joe has over 250 5 star Google reviews for a reason! Not only did he save me over $1,800 dollars a year, but he was also able to give me better coverage then what I previously had!” – Julia O.
Need Coverage for Something Else?
The Cedarburg, WI Shortcut Locals Use to Make Insurance Simple
Better Protection + Fewer Headaches.
Getting good insurance in Cedarburg shouldn’t be confusing or stressful. We’re a local Wisconsin agency, and we keep things simple with no hidden fees, no pressure—ever. We compare more than 20 trusted Wisconsin-approved insurers to make sure you get the best deal, then explain your real choices in plain language. You only pay for the coverage you actually need—nothing extra. We’re here to help, not push you around. You don’t have to sign up if you’re not ready—no strings attached.
Real, Local Agents, Not Call Centers.
Talk to the same local insurance expert every time.
We Shop 20+ Carriers for You—Free.
You Get the Best Deal. We Handle the Shopping.
No Extras.
No Overpaying.
Only what you need. Nothing you don’t.
Meet Your Insurance Agents
Real People. Local Help. No Call Centers.
Joseph Hoell
Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency
Brad Zacharias
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Brooklyn Walker
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Kyle Kollmar
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
When Cedarburg Families Switched Agencies — Here’s What Really Happened
Here’s what happened when real families moved both their auto and home insurance to a local agency they trust.
Ready to Find Your Best Rate?
It’s fast, free, and there’s zero pressure. You don’t even have to sign up.
Prefer to talk?
Call (262) 214-0999 or email info@hoellagency.com
Questions People Ask Before Switching to Us
How People Think About Insurance in Cedarburg, WI
There are days in Cedarburg when Main Street feels like something out of a postcard — especially with the old mill buildings and families picking up ice cream at Amy’s. People here say hello, and you end up waving at folks you’ve known since grade school, whether that’s by the library or outside Piggly Wiggly. It’s the kind of place where small things matter, since you always run into someone you know. Around here, folks keep an eye out for each other.
Auto Insurance That Fits Cedarburg Drivers
If you’ve ever taken Bridge Road early on a foggy morning or crept along Washington Avenue during Wine & Harvest Fest traffic, you know driving here isn’t quite city-driving but it isn’t sleepy either. We see deer dash across Hamilton Road, and that river valley fog can sneak up just as quick as our winter black ice. Dings from runaway shopping carts, pothole woes, the occasional fender bender out by Cedar Creek — this is the stuff we all deal with. Affordable insurance in Cedarburg WI means looking out for these little headaches, not just the big ones.
Home Insurance That Makes Sense in Cedarburg
Everyone’s place is a little different in 53012. There are sturdy bungalows close to downtown and country homes that sit back from the road. Water in the basement after heavy rains, ice dams along old eaves, and hail dings are old news to anyone who’s lived through a few Wisconsin springs. Power goes out, sump pumps work overtime, or a kid launches a baseball through the neighbor’s window — it happens. Our local coverage is based on the way houses act in Cedarburg, not just what looks good on paper.
Trusted Local Insurance Agency
This isn’t a chain and you don’t get a robot when you call. With Joseph Hoell Insurance, you deal with real people right here in town. We compare more than 20 carriers to get you a quote, and we actually explain the choices without any hard sell or gimmicks. Our job is simple: help you get good protection that makes sense — and treat you like a neighbor since that’s what you are.
Thanks for reading and for thinking local. If you want to talk things through or just check your options, swing by or give us a call. No pressure at all.
