4.9 Google Rating
(307+ Reviews)
Helping Appleton Neighbors Find Better Coverage with Less Stress.
We help you compare coverage, understand the options, and choose what fits best.
(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Kyle, Whitney, Megan or Tarah — Not a Call Center.)
*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up Required.
Helping Appleton Neighbors Find Better Coverage with Less Stress.
We help you compare coverage, understand the options, and choose what fits best.
(*You’ll Chat with Joe, Kyle, Whitney, Megan, or Tarah — Not a Call Center.)
*Most Clients Save $300–$600 per Year.
*Insurance Quotes are Free. No Sign-up required.
Insurance in Appleton, WI
Appleton residents and families count on Joseph Hoell Insurance for honest, local insurance help—no call centers or runaround. As your independent, hometown agency, we compare top carriers to find better coverage and rates. Most clients save hundreds a year while getting the personal service you deserve.Need specific coverage?
Meet Your Insurance Agents
Joseph Hoell
Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency
Kyle Kollmar
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Whitney Kovacs
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Megan Parmenter
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Tarah McKay
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Joseph Hoell
Owner
Hoell Insurance Agency
Kyle Kollmar
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Whitney Kovacs
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Megan Parmenter
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Tarah McKay
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Megan Parmenter
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Tarah McKay
Insurance Agent
Hoell Insurance Agency
Why Choose an Independent Insurance Agency?
Real, Local Agents
Talk to the same local insurance expert every time.
More Than One Carrier
You Get the Best Deal. We Handle the Shopping.
Coverage That Fits You
Only what you need. Nothing you don’t.
Home & Auto Insurance Coverage in Appleton
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Compare coverage, rates, and options with help from a local agent.
Home Insurance
Review your home insurance options with local guidance you can trust.
Other Specialty Insurance
We Can Help Beyond Home and Auto
“Joe has over 250 5 star Google reviews for a reason! Not only did he save me over $1,800 dollars a year, but he was also able to give me better coverage then what I previously had!” – Julia O.
Appleton, WI’s Shortcut for Getting Insurance the Easy Way
Better Protection + Fewer Headaches.
If you live in Appleton, you deserve insurance that actually looks out for you. We’re a real Wisconsin agency — right here in your backyard. No hidden costs, no pushy sales talk. We compare rates and coverage from 10+ Wisconsin-approved insurers for you, and walk through your honest options in simple language. Only pay for what fits your life — not someone else’s script. You can ask questions and get answers without signing up for a thing.
What Appleton Locals Say After Making the Switch to Us
Neighbors who brought their auto and home policies to us—and finally felt peace of mind.
Need Help Finding the Right Coverage?
It’s free, easy, and there’s no pressure. You can message a local agent or call us when you’re ready.
Prefer to talk?
Call (262) 214-0999 or email info@hoellagency.com
Questions People Ask Before Switching to Us
Getting Insurance in Appleton, WI Without the Nonsense
It’s easy to know when you’re home in Appleton. The Fox River runs slow right through town, and the trees that line College Avenue light up every fall. People around here still hold the door open for each other. You never feel rushed — there’s always time for a neighborly chat at the farmers market or waving to someone out walking their dog. Living here just feels comfortable, if you ask me.
Auto Insurance That Fits Appleton Drivers
If you’ve done the drive down Wisconsin Avenue during rush hour, you already know — Appleton drivers face their fair share of headaches. There’s the tricky roundabouts by the mall, deer darting out past Northland, and a good dose of icy mornings come December. When the roads turn to slush or it rains sideways off Lake Winnebago, you really want local coverage that does more than just look good on paper. We drive these roads, too, and we get what you’re up against.
Home Insurance That Makes Sense in Appleton
From the old Craftsman homes up near Lawrence to the newer spots in 54911, Appleton’s got all kinds of roofs and all kinds of problems. Hail can come out of nowhere in spring, and more than one neighbor has dealt with a flooded basement after a summer storm. Broken tree limbs, frozen pipes, even the occasional squirrel chewing somewhere it shouldn’t — folks here end up dealing with it all. We’ve been in your shoes, so if you need a quote or just want to check if you’ve got the protection you need, we can take a look together.
Trusted Local Insurance Agency
We’re not some chain or call center in another state. We’re Joseph Hoell Insurance, serving Appleton, WI. When you call, you get someone who knows your street and probably ran into you at Redliner or Festival Foods. We check with over 10 insurance companies for you. No pressure. No fancy talk. Just honest answers — and a promise that we’ll never steer you wrong just to make a sale.
Thanks for taking the time to learn about us. If you ever want to talk options or just have a question, give us a shout — no hassle, no rush.
Resources and Local Information
Neighboring Communities
Menasha
Little Chute
Grand Chute
Harrison
Neenah
Combined Locks
Greenville
Kimberly
Kaukauna
Darboy